- About the Lecture
-
About the Lecture
Ann Wolpert’s panel should set off alarm bells among academics who imagine they may enter blithely into a publishing agreement in the digital age.
Claude Canizares sets the stage, describing the transformative changes in academic publishing: the disappearance of a paper-driven industry (with limited and controlled copies of authors’ works) and the emergence of internet publishing, “where anything goes.” The inexorable consolidation of academic publishers has allowed “relatively small numbers to exert significant control.” This leads to conflict with institutions like MIT, whose mission is research and the untrammeled dissemination of knowledge. Canizares himself has been subject to copyright agreements that limit his ability to use his own work. “We’d like to make it much easier for authors,” says Canizares.
The archives of Britain’s Royal Society going back 350 years are available online today, says Thinh Nguyen, “but the catch is, you have to be a current subscriber to download” this content. Newton’s article on the invention of the telescope costs $9. “This is the essence of the current model: a gated community of information.” Nguyen’s open access movement attempts to smooth the way for academics to be published and for others to see and use their work. His Science Commons enterprise attempts to reduce legal barriers to scientific research. For instance, he hopes to allow internet users to conduct software searches of online journals—currently prohibited by many publishers. Nguyen encourages scientists who publish to consider alternatives to signing over copyright to publishers without first attempting to negotiate the terms of ownership.
In her job as intellectual property overseer for MIT, Ann Hammersla works to retain as many rights for authors as she can. She’s engaged in the challenging job of working out arrangements with publishers that enable authors to use their own materials in future work, in their classrooms, and to publish on the internet after first publishing in print. She sees an increasing demand by private and government funders for public posting of authors’ works, a demand that runs directly counter to the copyright agreements publishers insist on. Hammersla also counsels the audience to “be careful in what you use, whether text, images, sound or video. You can’t just download from the web. Someone may get grumpy if you use someone else’s material.”
The best way forward for individual scientific authors, declares Ellen Finnie Duranceau, is through “collective and institutional action.” Together, authors must demand in their publisher agreements the right to “share work as widely as possible,” which will increase their readership and citation rate; and the right to reuse their work flexibly, and to authorize others to use their work. Duranceau discusses “chilling stories,” including an MIT faculty member who gave a publisher copyright to his own hand-drawn maps, and then could not use them on his MIT OpenCourseWare site. She worries about scholarly societies that impose “digital rights management technology on consumers of technical papers,” permitting only single printouts of a paper or viewing only onscreen. Duranceau recommends an MIT amendment to copyright transfer agreements that entitles authors more access to their own work, and more access by others through public repositories.
Brian Evans sees an imbalance, where researchers and universities “are being preyed on by large companies.” Researchers lose rights to their own work, and libraries pay excessively for journals: Says Evans, for “every $10 thousand we pay to a publishing company, it’s $10 thousand we can’t do something else with at the Institute.” He exhorts his colleagues “to consider publishing in public access journals or starting one in your own field,” and to reduce copyright restrictions through individual negotiations. Most of all, faculty should come together to work toward uniform standards.Related Videos
-
Open Science and Scientific Publishing
Hal Abelson, John Wilbanks and Anna Gold
November 13, 2007
-
Copyright, Fair Use, and the Cultural Commons
Wendy Gordon, Gordon Quinn, Hal Abelson and Pat Aufderheide
April 28, 2007
-
Effective Examples of Educational Technology
Andrew Chien, Chris Mackie, Irving Wladawsky-Berger and Ashok Kolaskar
December 2, 2006
-
- About the Speakers
-
About the Speakers
Moderator: Ann Wolpert
Director, MIT Libraries
As Director of Libraries, Ann J. Wolpert is responsible for the MIT Libraries and MIT Press. The MIT Libraries consist of five major collections, a number of smaller branch libraries in specialized subject areas, a fee-for-services group, and the Institute Archives.
The Institute Archives and Special Collections preserve the historical records of MIT and the personal papers of many faculty members.
The MIT Press publishes about 200 new books and more than 40 journals each year in fields related to or reliant upon science and technology. The Press is widely recognized for its innovative graphic design and electronic publishing initiatives.
The Director's Institute responsibilities include membership on the Committee on Copyright and Patents, the Council on Educational Technology, the Deans' Committee, and the Academic Council. She chairs the Management Board of the MIT Press and the Board of Directors of Technology Review, Inc.
Prior to joining MIT, Wolpert was Executive Director of Library and Information Services at the Harvard Business School. Before working at Harvard, Wolpert was involved in management of the Information Center of Arthur D. Little, Inc.
Wolpert received a B.A. from Boston University and the M.L.S. from Simmons College. In 1998 she was nominated for and accepted into the National Network for Women Leaders in Higher Education of the American Council on Education.Claude R. Canizares
Bruno Rossi Professor of Physics, in the Department of Physics and the MIT Kavli Institute for Astrophysics and Space Research
Vice President for Research and Associate Provost
Thinh Nguyen
Counsel, Science Commons
Ann Hammersla
Senior Counsel for Intellectual Property, MIT
Ellen Finnie Duranceau
Scholarly Publishing Consultant
Brian Evans
Professor of Geophysics, Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences
Moderator
Speakers
- About the Host
-
About the Host
MIT Libraries
Video Player
Managing Copyright to Advance Research and Teaching
- Moderator: Ann Wolpert
- Claude R. Canizares
Thinh Nguyen
Ann Hammersla
Ellen Finnie Duranceau
Brian Evans - January 25, 2007
- Running Time: 1:41:23
