Video Player

What's So Natural About Natural Disasters?

Moderator: Rosalind H. Williams HM
David A. Mindell PhD '96 David S. Jones Meg Jacobs: November 15, 2005; Running Time: 1:27:40

About the Lecture

About the Lecture

It seems as if humans conspire to aggravate many of our worst ‘natural’ disasters. David Mindell brings to mind the massive gridlock on one side of an interstate highway leading out of New Orleans, following Hurricane Katrina. In all the planning for a mass evacuation from this flood-prone area, did no one think to use all lanes of this highway? This “glaring omission,” along with many others, says Mindell, is typical of a society that’s dependent on technologically sophisticated, large-scale systems. Disasters open and expose the workings and vulnerabilities of man-made systems, which normally remain invisible. Mindell notes that the prosaic networks surrounding us, from highways to electrical power, sewers, water, and communication, are all more or less necessary for life as we know it—but some are necessary for survival.

In earlier times, people saw divine retribution when earthquakes struck or volcanoes erupted. David Jones today sees a predictable phenomenon when disasters “collide with human populations:” the greatest harm nearly always falls on the poor and disenfranchised. This was true with last summer’s crop of hurricanes. It’s also true for heat waves, blizzards and tornadoes, which “like their more violent cousins have a preferential impact on the poor.” Earthquakes “are slightly more egalitarian,” Jones says, but in wealthier countries, our urban structures can better resist the shocks, whereas in poor nations like Turkey and Kashmir, little is left standing. Some epidemics have natural origins, then spiral out of control when they begin to circulate among humans, particularly those residing in the developing world. Jones believes we “could drastically reduce the mortality of disasters…simply by implementing policy based on current knowledge.”

Meg Jacobs sees a grim logic to the Bush administration’s “unnatural” response to natural disaster. “What might appear as a political gaffe is the result of a quarter-century effort to purge the idea that government should respond to disaster,” she claims. Look back to the energy crisis of the 1970s for the origins of this policy, because that’s when those in power today, Rumsfeld and Cheney included, “first cut their political teeth.” When the Arab oil boycott lowered American access to energy, leading to gas lines and a dramatic downturn in the economy, some politicians sought ways to soften the impact on people. Richard Nixon advocated energy conservation, but he also implemented a conservative free market approach to the energy crisis. From Nixon through current times, believes Jacobs, powerful people have “sought to undermine the legitimacy of state action from within government.” Jacobs says the Bush administration has used the crisis of Katrina “to advance a conservative agenda,” including the suspension of fair wage laws, reliance on individual charity and on corporations like Walmart.

Lecture Details

Location: Kirsch Auditorium
Stata 32-123

About the Speakers

Moderator: Rosalind H. Williams HM

Robert M. Metcalfe Professor of Writing Director, Program in Science, Technology, and Society

Rosalind Williams came to MIT in 1980 as a research fellow in the Program in Science, Technology, and Society. From 1991 to 1993 she served as Associate Chair of the MIT Faculty, and from 1995 to 2000 as Dean of Students and Undergraduate Education. Her latest book, Retooling: A Historian Confronts Technological Change (MIT Press, 2002) draws upon her experiences as a historian and MIT dean to comment upon our “technological age.” She is President-elect, Society for the History of Technology.

Williams receibed her M.A. in Modern European History from the University of California, Berkeley, and her Ph.D. in History from the University of Massachusetts, Amherst.

David A. Mindell PhD '96

Frances and David Dibner Associate Professor of the History of Engineering and Manufacturing Macvicar Faculty Fellow

David A. Mindell is the Frances and David Dibner Associate Professor of the History of Engineering and Manufacturing, MIT Program in Science, Technology and Society. He received a B.S. in Electrical Engineering and a B.A. in Literature from Yale University in 1988. He earned a Ph.D. from MIT in 1996.

David S. Jones

Assistant Professor, Program in Science, Technology and Society

David Jones completed his A.B. at Harvard College in 1993 in History and Science, pursued a Ph.D. in the History of Science at Harvard University and an M.D. at Harvard Medical School, receiving both in 2001. After an internship in pediatrics at Children’s Hospital, Boston, he trained as a psychiatrist at Massachusetts General Hospital and McLean Hospital. He joined the MIT faculty in 2005 as assistant professor in the History and Culture of Science and Technology. He also works as a staff psychiatrist in the Psychiatric Emergency Service at Cambridge Hospital.

Meg Jacobs

Associate Professor of History, Department of History

Meg Jacobs received her Ph.D. in 1998 from the University of Virginia. Her book, Pocketbook Politics: Economic Citizenship in Twentieth-Century America was published by Princeton University Press in January 2005.

During 1999-2000 Professor Jacobs was a Newcomen Postdoctoral Fellow in Business History at the Harvard Business School. In 2003-2004, she was a Charles Warren Fellow at Harvard University. Her current research focuses on the energy crisis of the 1970s.