SPEAKERS:
Robert Kanigel: Professor of Science Writing
More on Robert Kanigel
Thomas Levenson: Associate Professor, Program in Writing and Humanistic Studies
Graduate Program in Science Writing
Science Writing faculty website
Alan Lightman: Adjunct Professor of Humanities
Lightman's website
ABOUT THE LECTURE:
Robert Kanigel poses the central question of this panel: “The storytelling express is leaving the station. Do we want to jump aboard, or under some circumstances, stay where we are?” Science writing has matured as a discipline and genre, and for many writers, this means telling a story with what Kanigel describes as “a narrative arc: a cannon propelling you through a text, because of readers’ eagerness to know what’s happening next.” This implies some kind of linear movement, whether the writer focuses on “the smallest atomic unit” or a larger canvas. But Kanigel wonders if “there are circumstances when we don’t want stories.”
Thomas Levenson responds, “You can go a long way down the path of understanding science as a human activity without getting a story.” He offers the example of a writer who keeps a diary of a year spent in a laboratory -- what Levenson describes as “science travelogues.” But from his early experiences as a journalist, Levenson has found that “Science produces a certain kind of knowledge, but the activity of science takes shape within and is shaped by the world beyond science.” So he brings an historical, interpretative method to bear on his subjects, including Einstein. Says Levenson, “You get to make meaning out of the story you want rather than asking people to extract meaning out of a happenstance of facts.”
Alan Lightman ponders the role of science in novels, theatre and film. He offers several examples of “gripping and suspenseful” discussions of science within narratives, such as Michael Ondaatje’s novel, The English Patient and Michael Frayn’s play, Copenhagen. These authors avoid the didactic with a “motor that drives us through discussion.” But the very popular genre of science biography proves trickier to propel successfully. “In science, it’s more of a challenge to intertwine work with life because life deals with the inanimate,” says Lightman.
NOTES ON THE VIDEO (Time Index):
Video length is 1:27:05.
David Thorburn, Professor of Literature and
Director, MIT Communications Forum introduces Thomas Levenson.
At :35, Levenson introduces Robert Kanigel and Alan Lightman.
At 2:49, Kanigel begins.
At 13:26, Levenson begins.
At 25:28, Lightman begins.
At 35:32, the panel discusses a variety of science-writing issues.
At 51:50, general Q&A begins.
The information on this page was accurate as of the day the video was added to MIT World. This video was added to MIT World on 2005-08-15.
|
